Sunday, March 29, 2015
I came across the pamphlet translated below somewhere in the depths of the internet. It is a set of 60 theses proposed for debate in Florence ca. 1700, published with the title of Principal Conclusions... of Scotus. Some seem to be based on Scotus, some not, but perhaps based on later interpretations.
Conclusiones principaliores ex universa theologia subtilissimi doctoris Scoti.
Fr. Antonius Franciscus de Bononia, in conventu Omnium Sanctorum Florentiae s. Theol. Studens Generalis.
1. Aseity is the formal constitutive [feature] of God; existence is a quidditative predicate.
2. The existence of God can be demonstrated a posteriori, although not a priori.
3. ‘God exists’ [‘Deus est’] is a per se nota proposition.
4. The attributes of God are formally distinguished from each other and from the essence.
5. Creatures according to real being [esse reale] do not coexist with eternity, although they do according to objective being.
6. If God were able to will something new in time, this would not detract from his physical immutability.
7. God is invisible to the corporeal eye.
8. God is not naturally able to be seen by the created intellect, although he can be seen supernaturally.
9. God, by his absolute power, can be seen without the light of glory.
10. The divine essence can be seen without the Persons being seen.
11. It is possible for an impressed species to be representative of the divine essence.
12. There is inequality in the blessed vision, not only by reason of light but also by reason of the created intellect.
13. The divine will necessarily loves the divine essence.
14. Predestination to glory is prior to the prevision of merits.
15. Reprobation or damnation for punishment is posterior to the prevision of demerits.
16. The hidden mystery of the Trinity is evidently demonstrable by no natural reason.
17. There are only two divine processions, and neither more nor fewer are possible.
18. Relations of origin, formally distinct from the essence, do not bespeak perfection or do they involve imperfection.
19. The divine Persons are constituted by relative properties.
20. The absolute subsisting essence is given beyond the three personal subsistences.
21. The divine Father is perfectly blessed before he generates the Son.
22. The divine Word is produced by “speaking” [dictionem] but not through intellection.
23. The divine Word is produced from the cognition of the divine Persons.
24. The divine Word is not produced from the cognition of possible creatures.
25. The procession of the Holy Spirit is not generation, because it is in a free mode.
26. If the Holy Spirit did not procede from the Son, still he would be really distinct from him.
27. The incarnation of the divine Word was possible, although not naturally demonstrable.
28. The humanity assumed by the Word possesses its own existence [propriam existentiam].
29. The substantial assumption of any other creature was in the power of the Word.
30. Several Persons cannot assume the same nature in number, although two natures can be assumed by only one Person.
31. Christ is impeccable, not because of the hypostatic union, but through the beatific vision.
32. The merit of Christ was not unqualifiedly and intrinsecly affected by infinity [infinitate affectum]
33. Christ, whose grace alone was in the highest degree, did not satisfy from the entire rigor of justice.
34. A pure creature, aided by the powers of grace, could satisfy sufficiiently for the sin of Adam.
35. With no one sinning, still the divine Word from the force of the present decree would be incarnate.
36. The law of the holy gospel is prudently believable and to be believed [credibilis et credenda].
37. The assent of faith is not resolved into the authority of the Church, as into the formal object of believing
38. but in these aforementioned matters God is truthfully procaliming and has revealed mysteries.
39. Revelation, nevertheless, is not part of the formal object of faith, but only the necessary condition.
40. Falsity in no way is able to undermine divine faith.
41. Explicit faith in Christ under the concept of the Son of God is necesary by a mediate necessity for the salvation of adults.
42. It is probably that the habit of faith is educed from the potency of the subject.
43. Faith necessarily is discursive, either formally or virtually.
44. Faith is more certain than knowledge/science, utraque certitudine [?]
45. God and neighbor are loved by the same infused charity, and what was in the wayfaring state remains also in the homeland [patria].
46. Many angels can be under the same atomic species.
47. An angel is not in a place through operation, but through substance.
48. The angels are able to obtain species also from material things.
49. There are not as many representative species as there are objects.
50. The angels could sin in the first instant of their creation.
51. The cognition of the secrets of hearts is given to the angels.
52. The determination of the demons in evil does not come about from the inflexibility of their wills
53. but from the rejection of divine concurrence.
54. Original sin in human beings is not sin persisting morally.
55. Original sin consists in the lack of original justice and sanctifying grace.
56. In human acts there is found a true and proper principale of the voluntary.
57. A pure omission can be given without something positive.
58. A perfect voluntary act corresponds with a free one.
59. The sacraments cause grace morally, not physically.
60. The character of three sacraments, is it an absolute or relative form? Problem.
Praise be to God.
[These theses] will be publically exposed for contest at Florence in the church of All Saints, with the same one mentioned above responding. With the assistance of R. P. Seraphin of San Casciani, lector general of the same place and Custos of the Tuscan province. 1697. Month. Day. Hour.